Kitty Litter Cake

  • Prep Time: 45 mins
  • Total Time: 1 hrs
  • Servings: 20
  • Ingredients

  • 1 (18ounce) boxesspice cake mix or 1 (18ounce) boxes German chocolate cake mix
  • 3eggs( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1/3 cupoil( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 1/3 cupswater( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 (18ounce) boxes white cake mix
  • 3eggs( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1/3 cupoil( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 1/3 cupswater( or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 (6ounce) boxes vanilla instant pudding mix
  • 1 (18ounce) packages vanilla sandwich cookies
  • green food coloring
  • 12smallTootsie Rolls
  • 1new kitty litter box
  • 1new kitty litter box
  • 1Pooper Scooper
  • Directions

  • Prepare cake mixes and bake according to box directions (any size pan). Preparepudding, chill until ready to assemble. Crumble sandwich cookies in smallbatches in food processor, scraping often.
  • Set aside all but 1/4 cup.
  • To the1/4 cup of crumbs, add a few drops of green food coloring and mix using fork orshake in a jar.
  • When cakes are cooled to room temp, crumble into a large bowl.
  • Toss with half the remaining cookie crumbs and chilled pudding.
  • You probablywon’t need all the pudding, mix the cake and “feel” it, you don’t want it soggy,just moist; gently combine. Line litter box.
  • Put mixture into box.
  • Put 3unwrapped tootsie rolls in microwave safe dish and heat until softened.
  • Shapeends so they are no longer blunt, curving slightly.
  • Repeat with 3 more tootsierolls and bury in cake mixture. Sprinkle the other half of cookie crumbs overtop.
  • Scatter green crumbles lightly over top (chlorophyll in cat litter). Heat3 tootsie rolls in microwave until almost melted.
  • Scrape them on top of thecake and sprinkle with cookie crumbs.
  • Spread remaining tootsie rolls over top;take one and heat until pliable, hang over side of litter box, sprinkle withcookie crumbs.
  • Reviews

  • “I made this for a cake walk at my Daughthers preschool. It was the first cake picked. I don’t think something that makes people laugh is a waste of time”

  • “My sister-in-law runs a day care and makes this cake every year for Halloween. The kids beg for it! Granted, to the adults it may not sound very good, but the kids get a kick out of it.”

  • “It probably tastes really good, but what a STRANGE recipe!!LOL!!”

  • “I made this cake as a gag gift and it was a hit!As I was reading the comments that have been posted no one said if it tasted good or not. It may make you a little squimish, but it tasted great….”

  • “I think it rocks.I have made this before, and posted a picture at:https://www.recipezaar.com/search/getrecipe.zsp?id=3091&path=CAUTION:For people with a sense of humour ONLY!:)”

  • “I just finished cleaning out our cats litter pan and have NO IDEA why anybody would want to RECREATE the look of it in a CAKE!!! this is definitely in the To-each-their-own category!!”

  • “Although, It does LOOK absolutely disgusting, I think my kids would definately get a laugh out of this one!I think it is a really funny and cute gag, I will make it for the next potluck I go to, just to see the looks on peoples faces! Halloween would be the best time to make this one. very origianl.”

  • “Awesome cake! Made this for a family Halloween party, and everyone loved it! It looked so, so gross, but it was definitely a hit. I couldn’t find Tootsie Rolls at the store (I was behind the curve this year in getting Halloween candy…). So, I used the Chocolate Melts that I use to coat pretzels, etc. and melted them in an icing bag. Then I piped them onto the cake in “poop” patterns (ewww) and it looked GREAT! Thanks for a keeper!”

  • “I think that this is a great idea my kids found this recipe and can not wait to make it.I also DO NOTthink that it is a waste of time or money to make something that makes people laugh. Now posting negative comments to a recipe that you have no desire to make that seems like a waste of time.”

  • “This cake was very cool.Tasted good, but the “gross factor” was the biggest hit.Instead of Tootsie Rolls I used Little Debbie brownies rolled into poop.I used 2 boxes of cake, one spice and one german choco. cake.”

  • “I’m with the squeamish one.”

  • “I am soooo excited to make this…it is a tradition at my office to bring a “treat” on your birthday…my birthday falls on April Fools Day…know it’s a ways off, but I’m tucking this puppy aside for safe keeping – can’t wait!Thanks for a fun recipe- great post!!!!”

  • “I made this cake years ago when I was a volunter for our local animal shelter. We had a feline spay/neuter day where we “fixed” 100 cats at a reduced charge. All of the volunters brought in food for the day long event. I brought this cake and people were very reluctant to try it because it looked like the real deal. I guess the sight of the cake along with the smells created by 100 cats awaiting for their surgery was too realistic. Some people tried it (includin myself) and it was tasty. I took the leftiovers to the nieghbor kids who gobbled it down all the while saying “this is so gross!”Another time, I took it to a class full of 2nd graders and told them that my cats made something extra special just for them. I showed them the cake and the loved it and were grossed out all at the same time! LOL! They said it tasted good too.”

  • “My 10y/o daughter and her 10y/o friend made this for April Fools day.They had a blast doing it and the instructions were so simple even they could do it all by them selves!They made it exactly as the recipe called for, we loved it!The laughter, joy and tricking dad was worth a million!We used regualr chocolate cake and it was dark but wonderful taste.The girls renamed it to Pooper Scooper Delight.Our 14y/o son who has autism was struggling with it at first but when he saw the girls and daddy eat it well then he got the joke!We laughed and laughed.Thanks for all the fun and delisious recipe!”

  • “I made this cake for my daughter’s birthday and took it to her work at a pet boarding kennel. They had a great laugh over it and enjoyed the taste. I took whipped topping to serve with it. They even shared with the veterinary hospital next door. What fun! It took about 2 1/2 hours to make. I also made one for at home on her birthday with Grandma and Aunt/cousins in attendance. Their expression when they first saw it was priceless. “

  • “haha I made this for my father of “father’s day” because he always ends up cleaning the cat litter and he gets sooooooooo mad.He laughed so hard when he saw this! He actually liked the taste of it, too! I might add, instead of the German chcolate/spice mix I used Devil’s food cake mix and it turned out great!Love love love this recipe! Thanks!”

  • “We were going to make this, but another party goer didn’t know what to make, so we suggested this one for them and we made something else. This cake was the hit of the party, and although initially grossed out (naturally), my dh dove in, and convinced everyone to try it by explaining what was in it, and they all had a blast. The guy who made it (Mike) did a great job. Flavor wise it was terrific, tasting like a chocolate bread pudding of sort. Thanks for a great recipe, and the hit at the buffet table!”

  • “I made this cake for our Halloween party last year, hate to say but I think I was the only one to eat any of it.It was good but ours looked so gross no one wanted to even touch it lolI’ll put up a pic”

  • “How fun this would be to make!!! 🙂 But if litter boxes look that bad I’ll never have a cat LOL, jk.;-p”

  • “I wouldn’t use a kitty litter pan or litter scoop unless I knew the plastic they were made from was safe to use around food. For sure check the plastic number molded into them and make sure they are BPH free. They aren’t intended to be used around food so I’m guessing no special precaustuions are taken during their manufacturer.”

  •