Fluffer Nutter Sandwich

Fluffer Nutter Sandwich

  • Prep Time: 5 mins
  • Total Time: 5 mins
  • Servings: 1
  • About This Recipe

    “A old fashioned sandwich from our childhood days.”


  • 2sliceswhite bread
  • 2tablespoonsmarshmallow creme
  • 2tablespoons smooth peanut butter or 2tablespoonschunky peanut butter
  • Directions

  • Spread marsh mallow creme on to first slice of bread.
  • Then spread peanut butter on second slice of bread.
  • Then put both slices together, filling to filling.
  • Eat!
  • Then remember your childhood days.
  • Reviews

  • “My kids love these.They are a change of pace from the usual PB&J or peanut butter and honey sandwiches.”

  • “I love this sandwich!Some people look at me weird when I mention this; they know the sandwich combo but not by the “Fluffer Nutter” name.”

  • “Just like Mom use to make for me after school for a snack. Sure does bring back good memories.”

  • “AAHH! Brings back sweet memories!I add sliced bananas too and it’s oooh so yummy!”

  • “My husband is a die hard fluffer nutter fan.He would argue passionately with you that marshmallow creme is NOT the same as fluff.I personally had never heard of Fluff until I met him and I can’t tell the difference.Fluff must be a yankee version of marshmallow creme.”

  • “Took me 40 years to finally have one of these and now I’m so sorry I waited. DELICOUS!”

  • “Yum!Excellent recipe from my childhood.My husband doesn’t like it, but he’s European.They never like peanut butter!My son loves it also!I forgot about this until I ran into this recipe, thanks for posting this fun recipe from old times!”

  • “I love fluffernutters! I used smooth peanut butter and the marshmallow fluff and PB creamed together so well. Great sandwich, thanks a lot.”

  • “Classic! I ate these all the time when I was younger. I remember making them like it was y’day. Thanks for the recipe! And we did call them Fluffer Nutters here in FL. :)”

  • “You’ve gotta grill these like grilled cheese sandwiches! It’s the best!! :)”

  • “We love these.Brings back great memories.Don’t tell anyone, but I still enjoy these from time to time as an adult :-)”

  • “my kids took one bite.. gagged and said NO THANK YOU.. they all hated it. ALL 7 of my kids hated it. rather sad. sorry..”

  • “This has become my son’s favorite lunchbox treat.Thanks for posting!”

  • “Love this sandwich!But, I prefer the bread toasted.”

  • “YUMMY! I’ve always done them a bit differently. I mix the fluff and PB together in a bowl first (which makes it less messy to spread). I also add honey to the mix, and toast the bread a bit.”

  • “It was so fun to see this recipe in writing!It’s a favorite in our house.When we moved to Virginia, people thought we were crazy but my sons’ friends all eat them now!Thanks for the memories… Tracey”

  • “My 10 yo son will not eat PB&J’s, but he LOVES Fluffer Nutters….My brother used to eat them all the time as a kid and people thought he was crazy when he’d tell them about it.”

  • “This was one of my favorite sandwiches growing up. I was never much of a PBJ fan but love PBM sandwiches. My kids now love these too. I do not measure the ingredients- I just spread them on.”